Atlantic
From Rejection Wiki
Prose rejections
2018
Personal
Dear [Name]:
“Title” is literate and knowing, though a bit long for Atlantic purposes and not entirely persuasive. You’re plainly a writer, however, and I hope you’ll try us again.
Yours,
[Name] Fiction Editor, The Atlantic.
2011
Standard
Though the manuscript you sent has not found a place in The Atlantic, we thank you for the chance to consider it. Best of luck in placing it elsewhere.
Personal
As above with handwritten note on rejection slip.